Thursday, December 02, 2010

Friendly Competition - Talking Ed

Buy and Hold Versus Aggressive Trading

I have been visiting another blog of late (Ed's Talking Stock). It is an entertaining site where Ed discusses the market mood at the start of each day and posts his trades along with his daily and monthly stock performance. He is an aggressive trader, using leveraged ETFs and holding concentrated positions. Just for fun, I am setting up a portfolio that will be buy and hold for a year and we will see which approach fares the best.

My portfolio is a blend of my Magic formula stocks, with some financial stocks and insurance companies thrown in for good measure. My portfolio has 50 stocks and I am assuming a $100,000 starting investment (2,000 per stock). Without further ado, here is my Nifty Fifty (note I show the change for today, but inception to date is 0, so I am effectively starting it tonight - also, O do not show dividends, but I will be including them):

stock Initial Shares Current Daily Change Y-day Current Value Total Change
afam 35.17 56.87 35.17 -0.48% 2,010 2,000 0.00%
agx 8.43 237.25 8.43 0.84% 1,983 2,000 0.00%
amed 28.49 70.20 28.49 -0.94% 2,019 2,000 0.00%
apol 35.35 56.58 35.35 2.61% 1,949 2,000 0.00%
azn 47.99 41.68 47.99 0.84% 1,983 2,000 0.00%
cbst 21.20 94.34 21.20 1.05% 1,979 2,000 0.00%
ccme 15.87 126.02 15.87 -0.94% 2,019 2,000 0.00%
ceu 3.44 581.40 3.44 13.53% 1,762 2,000 0.00%
chke 19.81 100.96 19.81 -0.60% 2,012 2,000 0.00%
cmtl 30.70 65.15 30.70 2.21% 1,957 2,000 0.00%
cnxt 1.43 1,398.60 1.43 2.14% 1,958 2,000 0.00%
coco 4.24 471.70 4.24 3.67% 1,929 2,000 0.00%
csgs 19.02 105.15 19.02 -0.73% 2,015 2,000 0.00%
dell 13.65 146.52 13.65 1.79% 1,965 2,000 0.00%
dlx 22.02 90.83 22.02 -0.81% 2,016 2,000 0.00%
eesc.ob 1.90 1,052.63 1.90 0.00% 2,000 2,000 0.00%
eme 28.02 71.38 28.02 1.12% 1,978 2,000 0.00%
frx 32.24 62.03 32.24 -0.43% 2,009 2,000 0.00%
gme 21.15 94.56 21.15 4.34% 1,917 2,000 0.00%
hrb 13.37 149.59 13.37 5.36% 1,898 2,000 0.00%
idcc 34.71 57.62 34.71 2.87% 1,944 2,000 0.00%
ipxl 18.29 109.35 18.29 0.94% 1,981 2,000 0.00%
ksw 3.43 583.09 3.43 2.39% 1,953 2,000 0.00%
lnc 25.12 79.62 25.12 2.45% 1,952 2,000 0.00%
lo 81.74 24.47 81.74 -0.57% 2,011 2,000 0.00%
lps 31.13 64.25 31.13 2.88% 1,944 2,000 0.00%
mail 6.84 292.40 6.84 1.94% 1,962 2,000 0.00%
mpaa 11.68 171.23 11.68 -3.07% 2,063 2,000 0.00%
mrx 26.88 74.40 26.88 -0.78% 2,016 2,000 0.00%
msft 26.89 74.38 26.89 3.26% 1,937 2,000 0.00%
navg 50.17 39.86 50.17 0.32% 1,994 2,000 0.00%
nvmi 7.42 269.54 7.42 0.27% 1,995 2,000 0.00%
osk 30.50 65.57 30.50 4.81% 1,908 2,000 0.00%
ppd 65.17 30.69 65.17 0.15% 1,997 2,000 0.00%
prsc 17.48 114.42 17.48 -1.58% 2,032 2,000 0.00%
pwer 10.40 192.31 10.40 8.22% 1,848 2,000 0.00%
rtn 48.33 41.38 48.33 2.29% 1,955 2,000 0.00%
scei 6.76 295.86 6.76 2.42% 1,953 2,000 0.00%
sndk 48.00 41.67 48.00 2.35% 1,954 2,000 0.00%
solr 7.87 254.13 7.87 2.34% 1,954 2,000 0.00%
supg 2.60 769.23 2.60 -0.38% 2,008 2,000 0.00%
ter 12.43 160.90 12.43 1.30% 1,974 2,000 0.00%
tnav 6.86 291.55 6.86 8.20% 1,848 2,000 0.00%
tndm 14.71 135.96 14.71 -0.61% 2,012 2,000 0.00%
tsra 19.93 100.35 19.93 -0.75% 2,015 2,000 0.00%
uis 24.27 82.41 24.27 3.14% 1,939 2,000 0.00%
untd 6.86 291.55 6.86 3.16% 1,939 2,000 0.00%
usb 24.76 80.78 24.76 2.27% 1,956 2,000 0.00%
veco 45.07 44.38 45.07 0.27% 1,995 2,000 0.00%
vr 29.59 67.59 29.59 0.58% 1,988 2,000 0.00%
Totals


1.64% 98,387 100,000 0.00%

No comments: